Dog Collars vs. Dog Harnesses: which is better?

When it comes to outfitting your dog for outdoor adventures, the “collar versus harness” debate is a common one. Both have their strengths; heavy-duty versions of either can handle even the most rambunctious or hard-working dogs.

At Modern Icon, we make collars, harnesses, and leads that are tough — putting your dog’s needs at the forefront of our designs.

A Dog Collar is Standard — But May Lack Control

Our collars are heavy-duty and built to withstand even the most determined dogs. The design gives you control while allowing your dog to move freely. 

Our collars are perfect for situations where your dog needs to be agile and quick, like on a hike or during a training session. Our collars are made with your dog’s body in mind. They spread pressure evenly to avoid straining the neck while still giving you the upper hand if your dog decides to test your grip.

Compared to dog harnesses, collars are a simpler means of attachment and give you the option to attach identification tags, patches, and other add-ons — like Fi®GPS compatibility and an integrated handle on the 1.5” Summit Collar or the loop attachment with Apple AirTag storage on the Rigid Modular Collar. 

Ultimately, a dog collar is the piece of equipment that is always on your dog. With Modern Icon, you can have peace of mind knowing that your dog’s collar is solid, secure, and easy-to-grab to control your dog to keep them out of harm’s way.

We have the variety of colors and high-visibility options you need. Whether you’re on a night walk or just want your dog to stand out, we’ve got you covered.

Why You Might Need a Dog Harness

A dog harness gives you the most control over your dog while best distributing the strain on your dog’s body. When we designed our harnesses, we didn’t just think about the handler’s needs; we focused on what would enhance your dog’s performance while keeping them comfortable.

A harness is ideal for working K9s or just dogs full of energy. It distributes the force across their chest and shoulders, which is better for their anatomy and gives you greater control. This is especially crucial in environments where you need your dog to be secure and responsive, like during a hike through uneven terrain or when navigating a crowded area.

One of the top benefits of our harnesses is the integrated handle. The handle gives you the tightest control over your dog because it is attached directly to the body of the dog — rather than the distance gap between a leash and a collar. 

Our Patrol Harness is best for urban environments and is ideal for working dogs, bite sports, and scent work. The Patrol Harness is strong while still boasting a lightweight, minimalist design. It does not have a rear strap; however, meaning it cannot be used to lift the dog. That’s where the Tracking Harness comes in.

Our Tracking Harness is best for outdoor environments or intense situations — think bite sports or rugged outdoor adventures. This harness includes a rear strap that helps support the dog — allowing you to lift the dog over obstacles on the trail or help them get up and into a boat. This harness also includes a rear clip-in attachment point which is ideal for tracking (hence the name).

All of our dog harnesses give you the ability to affix ID patches like “Service Dog,” “Do Not Pet,” or “In Training” which can help keep your K9 focused on the task at hand. Our harnesses come in various colors with bright options. This way, your dog can be seen easily during your adventures.

The Bottom Line

So, are dog collars better than dog harnesses? We think it’s about choosing the right tool for the right job. If your dog behaves well on a leash and you’re going for a casual outing, our 1.5” Summit Collar is a fantastic choice. But if you’re gearing up for a more demanding adventure or need extra control, our Patrol Harness or Tracking Harness is your go-to.

Our collars and harnesses are built with your dog’s capabilities and comfort in mind, making them ideal for any situation. Whether you’re exploring the great outdoors or just taking a walk around the block, with Modern Icon, your dog will be ready for anything.